We went there twice this past year, the last time was in August. This place has gone so far downhill that it is now off my "radar scope." It took us almost as hour and a half to get a mediocre pizza...they wouldn't even bring out my salad for a full hour! I tried talking to the management, but they... More

My family and I used to go to Pontillo's all of the time when Sam and Betty were still alive because everything was great - the food, atmosphere, and service. Unfortunately I can't say the same about the newly re-opened Pontillo's. My boyfriend had a dressing-covered pepporicini dropped in his lap, yes accidents happen. But then, our salads were not... More

I'm from Batavia, and grew up eating Pontillo's, so I might be a bit biased, but they really have the best pizza I've ever eaten. They are known for their pizza, but almost everything on their menu is delicious. Their pasta is great and reasonably priced. They have great subs and wings (their mild are by far my favorite). They... More

This is the place where my mother got her first slice of pizza in the early 60s. It's still her favorite. More

A familly restaurant with reasonable prices. Hearty food with a nice selection of italian favorites. The highlights are the portions: if you're a light eater, order one meal for two. They also have a small but nice wine selection. We'll be back. More