Even though reservations were made weeks prior we still waited with a 4 yr. old child 1/2 hr. to be seated. The hostess appeared very confussed. The restaurant was only 1/2 full, but understaffed. Had to remind waiter to bring drinks, and the restaurant had ran of bleu cheese salad dressing. Prime rib and 3 orders of lobster mashed potaoes... More

Had dinner here and kept feeling Robert Irvine would show up. The place looks so dated I was tempted to grab a sledge hammer. Saying the food was mediocre would be a compliment. More

Down to our summer house we decided to try the Bayberry again. Our last time to dinner there was good. We understood from a friend that they had a piano player in the dining room this season. My wife and I love piano. Wednesday evening was a night to remember. This guy just kept on playing from the time we... More

Haven't been at the Bayberry in some time. Read other reviews and wasn't sure if we even wanted to go but we decided to anyway. Boy, were we pleasantly surprised. The atmosphere put us into a festive mood... right down to the real wood burning fireplaces. We had a sushi style tuna appetizer that was wonderful. dinner was equally as... More

The food was bland and boring. Even the kids meal was disappointing. The bar had a Sinatra tribute singer that was way too loud but happening for the over 55 set. I will NEVER go back. Avoid and save your money. More

On Summer vacation, our family and friends went to the Bayberry Inn as a group of 11 with 4 kids and we all liked it. The service was quick and kid friendly. Great food with many choices. Owner [Peter] introduced himself and showed the kids to the ice cream bar! There is a large dining room, separate bar with locals... More

YUCK!! We went to Bayberry and my husband got the crab imperial bake. He took one bite of it and had to spit it out. It tasted like clorox or a detergent, I wouldn't taste it but I smelled it and it sure did smell like it. It could be a once in a lifetime mistake or the dishes were... More

I've been to the Bayberry for the brunch and a few dinners. The brunch was overpriced for what you get (read pedestrian breakfast fare and a few mediocre lunch dishes) and it was supposed to be a "champagne brunch", which means I should not be hunting down my waitress after just one mimosa. They need to be more on top... More