Went here for a business lunch. The atmosphere was simple but very comfortable and not noisy at all despite being almost full to capacity. The service was friendly and professional. I had a great Paniini, my companion an excellent spinach salad. I have to say the dishes going past us as well as the coal over pizzas all looked amazing.... More

good byob place for a casual evening. good food. good service. friendly atmosphere More

Love the food here as well as the service. FLorham park pizza is the better bet for a large size pie... But for personal pizzas or Italian entrees (pasta, chicken parm, fish, etc) brick oven is the best. Also better than nonna's for entrees taste and presentation. Nonnas pizza is not bad but if u want pasta or chicken don't... More

I live approximately 40 minutes away and I come to this restaurant at least once a week. The food is always well prepared, the staff is always attentive and unlike a lot of restaurants, a OWNER is always on site, not just a manager. I usually get one of the daily specials, which are creative and very good. This is... More

My wife and I are long time patrons of Brick Oven who enjoy not only its great food but also its outstanding service!!! Without a doubt this restaurant has the best Bracciole of any restaurant in Northern New Jersey. Their salads and Calimari are also outstanding as is their bread. The waiters and waitresses are warm, friendly, and attentive without... More

I just wanted to say thank you to the owner and staff at Brick Oven. I brought a group of clients (12) to the restaurant and everyone raved about the food and service. It’s a nice touch when the owner comes over to ask how everyone’s food is and if we need anything. You found a new customer for life! More

I go to brick oven 4 x month, the service and food is so consistent. I bring new faces there all the time, no one is disappointed. More

I have been frequenting Puleo's Brick Oven for many year's now. It is a favorite hotspot for my friends and I. The food is awesome and the service is just as good. One of my favorites there is the Veal Chop Special..to die for. I am finding it very difficult to believe the negative reviews posted for this restaurant. More

Upon my visit to Puelo's Brick Oven I was greeted at the door by the owner, Chuck Puelo immediately. He is sincere and cares deeply about his customers, always asks how their day is going. The menu features some of the finest italian food in all of Morris County. The venue lighting gives the place a warm feel to it.... More