We really enjoyed the food and service. The only reason I did not give 5 stars is because the corned beef (an Irish staple) was too dry.
We had to try May Kelly's, as it was the No.1 restaurant in North Conway, according to Tripadvisor! Well, you're not wrong. We wandered in through the maze of rooms filled with Irish momentos, local ski history, and generally amusing antiques to find a huge menu, and fast friendly service. Super view of the mountains from the main dining area,... More
What a cozy and welcoming place to dine. The first time my husband and i ate here we ate in the pub which was very cozy and this trip last week we were 6 people and we got to sit in our own private room which was even cozier. Our waitress Krista was awesome and very helpful with menu decisions.... More
We visited on a Thursday night where they have a 2 for $26 special. This includes 2 appetizers, 2 entrees and 2 desserts. The food was excellent. The potato cakes with horseradish sauce were excellent. The service was a little slow, but they were busy. The atmosphere was fun and reminded me of a recent trip to Ireland.
This restaurant is so cool....it's like you are in someone's house with all the neat decorations and wall hangings. It is so cozy and wonderfully decorated. They have a bar in the middle, where sometimes entertainment plays. The seating is plentiful. The menu features down home comfort food. Everything is delicious - you can't go wrong with this restaurant. It... More
My husband and I ate here tonight, and it was so delicious! On Thursday's there's a deal where, for $26, two people can choose a small appetizer each, an entree, and a small dessert. You can't beat that! We both had the Irish potato cake appetizer which was yummy. For our meals, he had a glazed pork chop dish and... More
We went here on our last night, as we had tried the two previously Monday's when they are closed! I had Meatloaf, OH had Irish Mixed Grill, both meals were fine, but I wouldn't really recommend them. On the table next to us a Lady had ordered Curry and that looked and smelt divine! The also had some wonderful sounding... More
Service is great, atmosphere is like the ILA we all miss. Great pints and traditional Irish fare. If you day isn't living up to expectations, pull in and stay a while.
Visited Mays restaurant twice within a week..Fab food and amazing restaurant interior.. Olde worlde with lots of different aged artifacts... Large portions of home made food with losts of irish recipes. Delicious!! on a Thursday they have a three course for $26 for 2 people. We wers so full we had to go for a staunch walk after... Phew huge...... More
If you own or manage May Kelly's Cottage Restaurant and Pub, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing