Whenever I have gone there the line is out the door. Food is worth it though. Hope this place succeeds and moves into a better area with a bigger space. I believe they do catering though, I will for sure keep them in mind for that!

Although it's off the beaten path, it's worth a visit! I experienced great service, great food and a great value when I visited Fatty Lumpkins. It is in a small facility and I visited during the lunch rush, but they still served us quickly. I will be back again soon! Love the variety of sandwiches! The outdoor seating area was... More

Small, quaint sandwich shop in downtown Muskegon, but don't let their size or location fool you! These guys are awesome and offer a wide variety of sandwiches - hot or cold!

Been reading about this place ~ finally got there before 3:00 today. Had a How Now Brown Cow (roast beef, horseradish etc on wheat) ~~ omg good.. that's the best sandwich I've had in a long time - huge and full of good stuff, fresh tasting bread.. really awesome, just a perfect blend of everything ~ took a menu home... More

Not much to add to the other reviews claiming an excellent rating. My wife and I were given a social coupon and thanksfully took advantage before it expired. We both had one of their specials and mine came with the soup of the day. All of it was excellent. The only drawback is that, currently, their seating is limited. We... More

We heard about Fatty Lumpkin's from a coworker. He raved about the sandwiches and he was right! They have limited hours and are mainly a lunch stop. We would definitely reccomend it or order it to go... maybe even for a picnic! Everything tastes deli fresh and service is quick and friendly.

1st time visit today. Growing popularity makes this tiny place a bit clausterphobic. I can see them expanding soon. 3 different Ruebens and a tomato basil soup to die for!

Fun place with a good sandwich. It's kind of in an out of the way residential street. Very small inside with 3 or 4 tables. They pile the Boarshead meat pretty high. Expect to pay $10 for a sandwich and bag of chips. It's not to the level of a Manny's in Chicago or Katz's Deli in NYC, but for... More

After listening to many friends talk about Fatty's we finally had to stop. Now we're upset we took so long but have been back a few times since then. Good variety of sandwiches made to order and they're not afraid to try something different. Don't see what you want? Ask, they can probably make it up. The only drawback is... More