The pizza was a bit on the expensive side considering that the pizza was not that big. We got it as take out and took back to the campground.

The pizza was a bit on the expensive side considering that the pizza was not that big. We got it as take out and took back to the campground.
I have only eaten several items off the menu, Pizza is outstanding. Prices are reasonable. Convenient location with plenty of parking.
Less than average pizza - good as a last resort. First time I did not enjoy the crust of any pizza I order which says something!
Great, inexpensive place to bring the kids for dinner
Called and ordered 3 subs, got there and they said we only ordered 2. Didn't want to argue so waited over 10 minutes for them to make the 3rd. Subs were average and girl at counter was very nice. I've had their pizza which has been good in the past.
Semi-warm customer service. Bland pizza. A Greek Salad made with primarily iceberg lettuce and a few scant veggies. Not going back.
Hard to find tucked away in Foster Square but worth the effort. Great pizza at a reasonable price along with newly added grill items to the menu. Pasta dishes are well cooked and plentiful. Relaxed casual atmosphere. Next door is the Brewster Sports Bar, owned by the same people and a great place to catch your favorite team.
There were 3 of us on a Saturday night but they weren't busy. We should have taken the hint but we ordered anyway. I had a steak and cheese sub with extra cheese and mayo and my family had an eggplant parm and a veggie wrap.
They forgot the cheese and the mayo and when I brought it to their...
More
I actually really love this place. The pizza parlor side has a big screen tv and lots of tables and the Sports Bar side has the full bar and lots of local color! The pizza is excellent it is Greek style and the plain pizza is actually amazingly good. My wife prefers this style pie while I prefer the thin...
More
I have been frequenting this restaurant for years and really love their pizza and their plain salads, but honestly, after this many years, it would be nice to see someone smile at me. It is hard to imagine that they don't recognize me, but they never look like they have ever seen me before. Never a smile from anyone. Yesterday,...
More
If you own or manage Brewster Pizza House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing