The menus is different from most which was nice. We did try a lot, and the calamari was some of the best I have ever had. The soft pretzels, cocktail shrimp, and lamb sliders were all very good. The grandpa's stuffies were good, but found it odd that it was not served in a shell. The steak special, fish tacos,... More

Tried after several friends recommended and I REALLy wanted to like it...I didn't like it. The decor is sort of dark and everything we ordered was disappointing. The appetizers were better than dinners. This seems like a good bar, a place to go and drink & nosh but the dinner food was not good. I will try again because I... More

Its a good sign to see a full parking lot, so when we walked into the Starvin Marlin, we were greeted with lively music, and a happy dining and bar crowd. We had clams casino to start, good! For dinner, a lobster roll and fish taco. Fish taco was HUGE and i think the best i have had (and i... More

We ordered a variety of food , ribs, hamburgers, and fish. It was all delicious. Frys were really great too!

After visiting the Brewster Ladies Library we stopped here for lunch... Had the fish taco and the eggplant sandwich... My fish taco had fresh cod and the taco was toasted just right.... my friend had the eggplant and said he was awesome. Friendly lady waited on us. Not too busy which is sometimes nice!

We've eaten here before, but it has been a while. Sunday afternoon about 2pm and still pretty busy in here. Sam was great waitstaff and made sure we had the opportunity to ask questions about the menu. Unlike the review below, we felt we had plenty of food. I had the fish taco. Had heard it was great so I... More

My husband and I went for dinner at The Starvin Marlin this past weekend. A friend recommended this as we are so glad she did. We were seated straight away, which we thought was because of it being off season, but by the time we left the place was getting packed. We could tell that there were lots of locals... More

What a find! High end food at a reasonable price. Owner is most often on premises and very friendly. He listens to his customers as is evidenced that a special found its way to being on the menu: lamb sliders. The lobster tools: hot or cold are tremendous as is the hamburger with lobster. Try it. Do not be fooled... More

My family ate at Starvin Marlins a number of times over the last year (in season and out of season), and the experience and food were great everytime. My son and I loved the cold lobster roll (lots of big chunks of lobster), my wife says the fish 'n chips is the best on the Cape (she's spent her summers... More