While I can't say anything negative about the restaurant itself or its food, it seems altogether to be a place that attempts to put itself on a pedestal that it is unworthy of mounting. As I said, the food is good (4/5), the service is good (4/5), and the location is very nice (5/5), but the pricing and supposed atmosphere... More

Hemingways has the best Oysters on the Half shell. This is where you go for great Oysters on the Half Shell. The Menu has a very nice variety of things to choose from. They are changing over to have more draft beer in the near future. My only complaint is the Key Lime Pie has way too much crust. I... More

Enjoyed our dinner at Hemingway's. Our server was great! Portions were good. Their Key Lime Pie was awesome!

Meh. I really wanted to like Hemingways, and I have given it a couple of tries. Unfortunately, all of the visits have ended with me disappointed in the food, paying too much for mediocre food, in one of the best places to have fresh seafood in the world. It is a beautiful restaurant, and the service was good. I hope... More

Great atmosphere! We sat outside and the view of the bay was beautiful. Had the Cuban sandwich and it was good- nothing I would right home about specific though. My child had the kids grilled fish, and that was awesome!

At the last minute we decided to stop in Hemingways for dinner-expecting fairly good food and atmosphere in a chain touting Ernest Hemingway's love of the sea. The staff was nice, the decor quaint and our waiter after an initial average first impression turned out to be professional, unabtrusive and a good guy. BUT what stood out was the best... More

Has mostly fried food, had water to keep the bill lower, but it was still expensive. The chairs are so long you can't lean back.

We just returned from a trip to Pensacola Beach. We checked out (and ate at) all the better restaurants the island... my approach to travel eating is I want something that is unique and memorable. Hemingway's is the best overall experience. Excellent food with unique menu combinations. Not cheap but not overpriced. We ate there twice. Quick comments about the... More

Visited during lunch. Great prices, excellent food with amazing view of the water! Had the grilled shrimp; absolutely the best I've ever had...sooooo good! Others had shrimp po-boys & they loved it...also raved about the bread. Substituted my rice & beans with fries - delish! Hostess was dry but our waitress made up. She was delightful & knew the menu.