The service was very - very slow, and it wasn't that busy when we where in here. I had the Reuben and it was very good. My wife had fish, and it tasted fishy. The staff seemed confused on what to do and maybe how to do it.

The service was excellent. I love the variety of food offered and the prices are not unreasonable. My friends and I ate their several times during our stay on Marco Island.

Yum! This place is excellent! Had the burger. Fries are hand cit and fresh! Delicious! You won't be disappointed? Easy walk from the Hilton across the street.

Waked over from the Hilton on Sunday afternoon looking for a late lunch and was happily impressed. Several people at the bar and the a few more eating at tables was a good sign as it going on 3:00 pm. We both had the Reuben and were really impressed with the corned beef. A home made brisket sliced thick and... More

We visited O'Donoghue's twice during our week long visit and both times the food was excellent. Shepherd's Pie was incredible as was the Tri-Colour platter (with the exception of the wings but they are not Irish!).

I love Irish music and it was great to find an Irish restaurant on Marco Island. Just so you know, this restaurant has moved from 969 N. Collier to 591 S. Collier. Our GPS had not been updated and we went to their old location before figuring out that they took over a different Irish pub's location. There was a... More

Great time with our family on spring break. Great food and live irish music. We highly recommend for families.

First time visitors to O'Donoghue's, although our dining companions make this a favorite. And now we see why they do. The O'Donoghue's Red served with Guinness in the black-and-tan was lighter than other offering have been in the past, and perked up the drink just right. The appetizer-sized shepherd's pies were right-sized for two of the diners, and the entree... More

Great improvement over the other location, clean and well done. The food we had was good and my Irish husband felt right at home.