We had a great dinner with recommendation form Sherry, I had the Father's Day special, prime rib and lobster I'm sure we will be back before we leave town.

This place is off the beaten path ... recommended to us by the woman at our hotel. A little tough to find. The restaurant needs better signage off the main road. The staff were friendly & very helpful. Our meals were excellent. Will definitely return.

Although the only seafood I had here was a conch kemchee roll the steak poboy was outstanding. We had 2 kids meals that were also fine. We will be making another stop here before we leave.

We've been coming to Castaways before but this time our experience was so different from the first time we ate at Castaways. Our first time, we had this lively waiter (i think Zack) who was so helpful and had so many suggestions for us to try. This time, our waitress couldn't offer any suggestions and when we asked how the... More

This is an out of the way, off the main drag kind of place. The food was very good, and the service was also good, with a really broad menu selection. For something other than the fried seafood rest in town, this is a great option.

The food was fabulous. We visited Dec 31, 2012. We are planning our next trip to the keys and this location is on our list to visit again.

Zack was our server and he was very attentive, we never waited for anything! We even asked for something that wasn't on menu and they made it for us. It was excellent! The outdoor seating was so peaceful and relaxing it made for a great lunch. I reccomend visiting.

Lunch was good and service was fair. But when you visit the Keys you have to slow day and relax Patience is a must-chill have a cold beverage.. Prices varied and was fair. They have a great Happy Hour menu. Very clean overall, They have pictures of the restaurant t through out the years and interesting decor. very pleasant experience.

I stopped in here with my friends to celebrate a newly graduated animal doctor. We had some of the crab dip (Maryland natives know good crab dips) which was outstanding and all had some of the seafood and snacks. Everything was great tasting, giant portions, and reasonably priced. The spot is authentic and fun and the drink menu has some... More