This pizza was a bit strange. It was tasty but not really my favorite. The crust was not cooked quite enough....the sauce was tasty, the cheese was stringy.

This pizza was a bit strange. It was tasty but not really my favorite. The crust was not cooked quite enough....the sauce was tasty, the cheese was stringy.
Got a sunny surfer beach bread and a cheese steak for my superbowl party and it came faster then they told me. The kid who delivered was polite and funny. All the food was phenomenal. I highly recommend eating here if visiting the Fort Myers beach area.
Whenever I want to have some good pizza on the beach, I make sure to make it a Surf Pie. The customer service is great and the pizza is, too. The price is right. Truly, the best on the beach.
Great pizza, delivered by a guy on a skateboard-can't get much more FMB than that! New owners Dave and Amy now have thin, thick and gluten free crust pizza. Good sauce and toppings too.
Went to there old location last year! What a difference a year makes. Staff was literally stoned! They were over an hour behind on a pickup order of 4 pizzas. They were under cooked ( because of the rush I am sure). This is not the Same pie as it used to be, stay away!!
We vacationed at Fort Myers Beach and wanted good pizza, we found it at Surf Pie. Very good pizza and beach bread, delivery was convenient right to our resort.
Pie crusts were charred literally! Called to complain and asked for a reorder-thought we'd give it another try. Received two mired burned pies. I can't believe an restaurant operates this way. We will never order from here again! Don't take a chance and just order from another place!
We had a night where we really did not want to go out and I had seen reviews for Surf Pie so we decided to place an order for delivery. Well, it was delivered in a very timely manner, maybe 20-30 minutes and the pizza was excellent. Thin crust like people said, cheesy and ample toppings. As a last minute...
More
The beat pizza I have ever had. Thin crust, plenty of cheese and toppings and tasty. Very budget friendly and they deliver. I places an order for deliver and was tol 34-40 minutes, which is fine, but we got it in amout 20 minutes. Wanting to take one home with us.
Being from Chicago, we are pretty picky about our pizza. We felt like staying in one evening and decided to order from Surf Pie. They delivered it to our hotel (quickly) since I didn't know where it was to go pick it up. The crust is super thin which is not what we are used to. But it was so...
More
If you own or manage Surf Pie, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing