Due to a heavy rainstorm on Saturday evening (May 11) it took us forever to find a parking space near the restaurant -- they should try to get parking from nearby offices that are closed on the weekend. We had a table on the second floor which can be loud due to the low ceilings. The clam chowder was "warm"... More

an old inn now serving as a three story restaurant near the water, not quite in downtown. good pub atmosphere, friendly service. huge portions of food, all well-prepared; extremely reasonable prices

Spent the day in Mystic and headed here for a late lunch – glad we did. We had read the reviews and about the history so sounded interesting. We ate at the Pub which has a very casual and inviting atmosphere – very rustic. We ordered the Clam chowder, Lemon Crusted Chicken and Fish & Chips – all excellent, good... More

Honestly had one of the worst and most unflavorful meals here!!!! Not even sure how its # 1!! It may be the oldest restaurant in mystic but I'm smh as to why ppl think its so great?!!! Crowd is def not hip either, most ppl looked like they were dressed from the time period the place first opened! I had... More

Super restaurant on the water . Ate in the downstairs pub. tables were a little tight but food was delicious also had a good selection of local beers and had a hard to find Shed Mountain ale

This is one of our favorite restaurants, for lunch or dinner. We almost always eat in the bar, which is cozy in winter with the fireplace going, and the attractive stone and wood walls. The dining rooms upstairs are also charming, and reservations are accepted up there. The place is usually busy, and there is often a wait for the... More

group dinner, about 15 or so people. the place was packed, but the service and the food was fabulous. A must!

We have eaten lunch here twice and both times were great experiences. This historic building is a treasure! You can choose to eat downstairs in the pub, or upstairs in the restaurant, The pub has a rustic charm that makes you feel like you are sitting in a pub in England 200 years ago. The restaurant is beautiful and has... More

We loved this Inne. It is a restored property, with all the charm. The food was delicious. The menu is diverse, and traditional meals are prepared with a unique touch. My husband enjoyed an appetizer of artichokes stuffed with lobster. I enjoyed an entree of salmon, prepared with thinly sliced peppers of different varieties. So good.