My wife and I love this place. Sadly we always order the same thing, because it is what we like. Fried Calamari and alligator tenders each with a side salad. We share both dishes and it is plenty. Love the gator and squid.

My wife and I love this place. Sadly we always order the same thing, because it is what we like. Fried Calamari and alligator tenders each with a side salad. We share both dishes and it is plenty. Love the gator and squid.
Well, it's been a long while since we've been back here. We know that management changed a while back. With this change has not been the best of changes.
As a mother's day dinner I hoping it would of been great for my whole family.
My son and husband's food was not great or good either. The pizza was terrible...
More
What strikes me about the 2 Islamorada restaurants we visited (Ashland and Myrtle Beach) is how QUIET they are. The restaurants are very big and always filled with people, but whoever designed them is a genius because the atmosphere is so pleasantly quiet. We appreciate a meal enjoyed without hearing every conversation around you and without a background of blaring...
More
We were on our way home from a meeting and stopped at the Islamorada Fish House. Being a Monday at 1:00 it was not to busy. The wait staff was attentive and it is a neat place, huge fish tank to keep your mind occupied.
The food was good and a good value. I had a crab cake sandwich that...
More
I had coconut shrimp and it was great. The dipping sauce that came with it was a little sour tasting, so I just didn't eat it. The french fries and slaw were great. I would go back again for sure. They have an extremely big fish tank right in the restaurant for viewing too.
I had opportunity to go to the Islamorada Fish Company in Ft. Lauderdale, FL, was much better experience than this one. This version is OK, but nothing to rave about. The food tastes good, but the prices are high for the value. The décor was NOT up to IFC's usual, and very surprising given that they had some wonderful choices/possibilities...
More
There was a really long wait. the food was good but not memorable, the prices were a bit high and the portions were kind of small.
Excellent service. Food was good but not great or fantastic. Nice to watch the fish tank. We have eaten here many times. NEVER order the fish and chips unless you really, really like the breading part. Nice salad. Last visit we both ordered shrimp and scallops...ok but nothing special about the dish and I have had much better scallops.Prices reflect...
More
We were cruising down I-95 after many hours of driving and feeling rather peckish we decided to look for a place to eat. We couldn't stomach another fast food meal so we focused on signs that looked to be real restaurants. I saw a sign on I-95 for the Islamadora Fish Company and made an exit post-haste. Following the signs...
More
This is a nice restaurant (located within the bass Pro Shop) with pretty good seafood offernings and reasonable prices. We enjoyed the fish and chips and loved looking around the Bass Pro Shop after our lunch.
If you own or manage Islamorada Fish Company, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing