After returning home from our honeymoon last week, my husband and I decided to treat ourselves to dinner at the Witchery - somewhere I had always wanted to go to. We reserved a table in the Secret Garden part of the restaurant which was lovely and atmospheric and the service was truly impeccable. However, we both felt let down by... More

We booked to go for lunch on the two course special offer in March 2013. The restaurant is a stones throw from Edinburgh Castle. You walk down a stone alleyway and a staircase into the magical dining room. Staff took our coats and showed us to our table. It had an intimate feel despite being very busy. We started by... More

My friend and I went for Lunch,we chose the 2 course set lunch.It really was excellent.The staff where friendly and attentive,beautiful,interesting surroundings and a lovely relaxed atmosphere.It isn't a "cheap lunch" but we felt it was good value for money.Look forward to going there again next time we are in Edinburgh.

We have had such exceptional meals everywhere we have gone on our visit to Edinburgh; but, the Witchery was very disappointing. Starting with the bread, everything was mediocre. My friend had the dish called "three little pigs" and said that it was salty and not what she expected. I had the Jerusalem Artichoke Tart with braised leeks. The leeks were... More

We went to the Witchery for a 40th birthday celebration. The experience was very good until the food arrived. It was over cooked and cold. We had waited so long for it and were very hungry so we just ate it!!! It was half term so maybe the usual chef was on holiday?

A real let down. Expensive disappointing food. Scallops ordinary, asparagus pulpy and inedible, lamb chop chewy. Desserts lovely though. Spanish red wine acidic,but maybe just my bad choice. Cold at our table due to the door being left open, but closed on request. Complained to duty manager about the disappointing food, but I didn't sense any genuine concern and no... More

Have eaten here twice both times 10/10 romantic great food and wine,this is one of my favourite place in Edinburgh always a treat. Go and spoil your selves u wont be disappointed

The surroundings are beautiful, the staff are 5 star the food is a delight. Having just visited for the 4th time my husband and I will absolutely be back again soon!

We needed somewhere rather late in the evening because we'd arrived late. The Witchery was open and stylish. The food was Scottish style and fine, though the portions were small. The waiting was effective. The wines were very over priced with a markup of about 5 times.