The cracked conch is to dye for - very reasonable prices and friendly service. The only caveat is that Jay is the only cook, so if there is a crowd be prepared to have a few drinks and wait while watching the beautiful sunset on the deck. A good reminder to slow down and enjoy the island life while you... More

I live in Deep Creek (South Eleuthera), and we stopped at this restaurant after a day trip to Spanish Wells. We requested to sit outside, and missed a dinner rush by about 10 minutes. There was one waitress outside, and we had to call her over to get her attention every single time we wanted something, whether it was to... More

This turned be our favorite dinner spot. There is a huge deck with plenty of seating and a great view for sunsets. Server needed some help on the busy evening we were there but it was overall a great evening. Homemade chocolate ice cream was excellent.

We were looking for a relaxing spot with a view and seafood. We arrived well before sunset and had a cold Kalik before dinner. The sunset was beautiful as the sun went down over a small island that reminded me of the Arizona. I had broiled grouper with peas and rice and green beans. It was a generous portion of... More

Fantastic location looking back to Governor’s Harbour, basic menu, but food pretty good. Sunset was great!

The restaurant is in a lovely spot with the sun setting right in front of you. It serves great conch salad. The other dishes we had were fine, although I think I would avoid any baked desserts as the cheese cake was dry and stale (I think they buy it in as opposed to making themselves). Staff are lovely, very... More

old or new, this place still has the same bad quality of food. You can get this view anywhere so why go here? Yuck. There seems to be an ongoing food quality issue with several of the restaurants around town. The food is just bad here too.

The New Sunset Inn (although the name has reverted back to simply the 'Sunset Inn'), remains on top form. I wrote over a year ago extolling the food at this restaurant and the same is still true. The Sunset is in a perfect position in the bay just beyond Governor's Harbour on the Queen's Highway - you can't miss it.... More

We stopped in at the Sunset Inn for dinner and to watch the sun set over the Caribean from there outdoor dining patio. The service was friendly and the conch salad is to die for. They also make homemade ice cream which was yummy!