My family has been to Carmine's each time we visit the Atlantis and we love it. This year was no exception...the food was all very good. We ordered a Cesar salad and 2 entrees for 6 people and it was e perfect amount....we all had enough to eat and left happy once again. Would recommend Carmine's to anyone visiting at... More

I was taken to dinner here by two very close friends. We were seated quickly at a nice table and given the menu. We were warned that portions are very large - in other words, 3 people could easily order one appetiser, one main course, and one desert - provided you could all agree. We actually decided to order two... More

This is very good Italian food. As with ALL the restaurants in Atlantis, it is overpriced. We considered the calamari as an appetizer, but reconsidered after we saw the $42 price tag. For an appetizer! On the plus side, they did provide great bread and olive oil with garlic to start. We also ordered a garlic bread appetizer which was... More

Ate there twice in a week. The cost is reasonable for the quality and quantity of food while at Atlantis. We had reservations one night and just walked in the second time. We were seated right away each time. The service was excellent and so was the food. The lasagna was fabulous and was about 10 layers. We also tried... More

Food was very good, service was good (by Atlantis standards, which are generally not great). However, I don't recommend it unless you are part of a large group. We were a foursome, and we had to agree on two entrees (still had tons of food left over). Portions are so huge that everyone can't really get what they want, but... More

We go to Carmines at least once every 6 months. Food is fantastic! Portions are family sized which makes this restaurant really affordable if you order correctly. You only need one entree for every 3-4 people. The salad and garlic bread is to die for and the staff is friendly.

I came here with a group of 8 people and I would only recommend this place for large groups. The portions are HUGE. One entree iof chicken and one pasta is still too much for 8. We also got a salad and the cheesy garlic bread. The garlic bread was ridiculously good! The salad was wonderful as well! It has... More

Make a reservation before you leave on your vacation. Great place to take the whole family. One plate can serve 3 adults.

Would rate this lively place as good; not quite up to very good. Best attributes are enormous sharing-sized portions and friendly service. Perfect for families or large groups. Carmine's is adjacent to the marina at Atlantis along with shops and restaurants so nice for a stroll before or after