I have been here many times since Greg took ownership. It is friendly and willing to accomodate any diet or taste. Some of the appetizers are a must try - and i tend to like those the best. I have also done oma case - where you just let Greg decide what and when - a marvelous experience. One hint... More

We chose Old Stone Farmhouse because it was rated number 1 on tripadvisor. The atmosphere is intimate and romantic. It is a bit of a ways from anything, right near the mahogany golf course on the north side of the island. The appetizers were delicious, the BLT cesar salad, the wahoo ceviche etc.! One caution is that the appetizers are... More

Very few restaurants can boast a truly unique atmosphere, wonderful food and excellent service, but this place can! Not only the best restaurant on the island, but the best restaurant my wife and I have ever been to. I doubt any of you will be dissapointed.

Old Stone Farmhouse maintains a consistent accent on good service and a wide ranging and eclectic menu. If you are a meat eater, this is the place for you, with exotic meals available every time I have dined there. The selection is much more limited for the vegetarian in the group, but the chef can get creative with mix and... More

I think they served very good quality food but the flavor and service was just okay not great. Some in our group had the filet and others had the fish. The potatoes were cold. It was very novel being escorted to the kitchen to see the behind the scenes happenings. Their wine selection was excellent. Their outside bar area and... More

Always a favorite on St. Thomas. Consistently good, lovely owners who have brought a refreshing quality of food and wine to the island of St. Thomas.

Drew McHolm and Jessie were so entertaining while we enjoyed their musical abilities and personal banter. Our waiter was so attentive with checking on our drink order while we were relaxing in the patio area after dinner. Wonderful dinner and we loved how they took us into the kitchen area to speak to the chef about each of their main... More

If I could give this a 10 I would. From the moment you pull up to the time you finally leave it is the most incredible experience. We sat down and given info on dinner options and was then taken to the chef who showed up the entrees and explained in detail how they could be coked. The chef was... More

The place was nice and they take you to the kitchen, but it was not my favorite meal