What a great place to dine and the history of the Lighthouse adds to the allure of this location. Started with beet salad and it was excellent. Ordered Carmel Road Pinot Noir which was fantastic. My wife had the Rib eye steak special. It was huge and therefore afforded me the opportunity for more than a few bites. I ordered... More

We took dinner here during our recent vacation having seen the reviews. The location is unbeatable even if there is a climb to it if you are on foot and not every table has a view.. Although the food was excellent we found the menu a little limiting and not over inspiring.. The service was very good but we we... More

We were staying at the Reefs Hotel, and took a short walk up to the Dining Room for an 8:30 dinner reservation. This is a very cozy little restaurant with excellent food. I had the beef fillet MR, and it melted in my mouth. She had the salmon, and said it was excellent. The service left a little to be... More

We had a gorgeous dinner with impeccable service at Gibb's Hill Lighthouse. It's worth eating there just to see the dining room and the gorgeous views. It was a very cool experience. The food was lovely. Highly recommended!

The Service is Excellent,food is excellent,we were staying at the reefs hotel,we booked in at the the dining room restaurant,what a welcome,by the staff,we got the conner table,perfect view,we had a nice cocktail which made my night so special,best Maitre d very jolly,we would recommend the place,we would love to come back on my next visit.. George n jessica

The food is good value especially for the area but the service was not good. Not offered the dessert menu, not offered coffee and not asked if I would like another glass of wine, . The put 17% service charge onto the bill so you might expect better. After my feed back the service charge was removed. A superb location... More

Pete, the manager, from the gold floor, at the Fairmont, suggested and made the reservation....food was, as they say, spot on! Chef came out, so nice of him, like he wasn't busy try to get food out, so incredibly gracious....the server and maitre d, so nice, (see my pictures!) - started with sea scallops in a citrusy vinaigrette (and champagne!)... More

This is a very small and cozy restaurant at the bottom of Gibbs Lighthouse. They have changed the chef and menu and I think they are struggling a little with an identity. I have been twice in the last couple of weeks and it is not consistent. The pizza dough is either nice and slightly fluffy or it looks like... More

Casual and tasty lunch, drinks, nice views, friendly staff. They actually kept the kitchen open for us because we took a while walking up from the Fairmont Southhampton, and were expecting us. The host made sure to provide us with a number for a cab service so we could call for a ride from the gift shop after exploring the... More