This was my second time in San Diego and I will stay at the Keating next time. The hotel is in a great central location. The staff are friendly and helpful. Despite some other guests criticising the fusion design of victorian and modern design, I loved the oversizes bath sinks, walk in shower especially. People shouldnt blame the hotel if... More

The Keating is special.Our room was large,funky in a modern Italian look,and very comfortable. The location is...right in the middle of everything.You can walk to Petco,the water,and a million super restaurants. HOWEVER...what makes The Keating go from "special" to GREAT...is their staff.Their eagerness to make our visit fun and complete was matched by their personality. And among them all,Brentney was... More

Costly design errors.I agree with Mark H review. I am a kitchen and bath designer by trade. The beauty of a victorian would best be accentuated by a more transitional approach, as the deathly dark hallways reminded me of a Halloween haunted house venue. I really applaud the effort on paper, but the real life effect was underwhelming and missed... More

First let me say that some members of the staff are genuinely interested in guest comfort, however these employees must say "I am so sorry, that shouldn't have happened, what I can do for you is..." about a zillion times a day. From airconditioning and room fan failures, to water dripping through ceiling from rooftop units ("we can assure you... More

A friend and I stayed at the Keating for Business. I make a habit of staying in boutique hotels wherever I go. i am a designer, and always love to see how different people approach hotel design and service. The Keating, while staffed by very nice people, ranks quite low in my boutique experiences. Design-wise, the idea of sleek. Italian... More

From the moment I called & spoke with the Concierge to the time we checked out, Every aspect of the Hotel Experience was 5 Stars! Sincerely, couldn't have felt more "At Home". We used a Groupon and they still treated us marvelously! (Many times that does not happen with Groupon...) Unfortunately the restaurant was closed for renovation... Our only negative... More

Keating was a top notch hotel. From the staff that meets you at the curb to the turn down service at night. The hotel was full of historic architecture with a modern touch. I would recommend anyone to stay here for a weekend retreat.

After reading some reviews on this property, I was initially skeptical. However complaints about the noise were unfounded. There was one rowdy group we encountered in the halls, but we slept well both nights -- and these were Friday and Saturday. Of course we were out fairly late -- it is the Gaslamp, after all. Two big pluses are the... More

I was beyond impressed with the staff, amenities, personalization and I could go on and on about how wonderful it was. I stayed for the weekend with my boyfriend and his mastiff dog who were visiting from LA. Upon check-in ALL of the staff knew the dog's name, they knew what company I worked for in San Diego amongst many... More