Thanks to the reviews on TripAdvisor I felt that I was led to the absolute best place to stay ever on Put In Bay. I prepared a 2 night 3 day trip to allow my girlfriend to visit PIB and enjoy a relaxing week mini vacation and was unsure of where to stay initially. I have visited PIB 4-5 times... More

We just had the best weekend stay on the island. We couldn't have picked a better place to stay. The location was great, the service was excellent, and the home was so charming! We loved having the bikes to ride around the island. Breakfast was delicious...my husband wanted both recipes to try and make them at home. We can't wait... More

My husband and I took a short (3 night) trip to Put in Bay and stayed at The Anchor Inn. We stayed in the Vintage Room which I believe, is the only room that does not have an in-suite bathroom. The bathroom is located directly across the hall from the room and was not really any issue for us although... More

The anchor Inn Bed and Breaskfast was a great place to stay for our weekend visit. Its location was ideal. The house and yard were very relaxing and quiet. The rooms were great, clean and decorated very nicely. The back yard was a nice place to relax late in the day and evening. We will definitly be back. More

We stayed overnight last weekend. It was a nice B&B; however, we found our room (upstairs garden/balcony rm) to be a bit on the small side - bathroom was very tiny - if you are over 160 lbs the glass corner shower unit would be a challenge - and while the room was clean, the ceiling fan was dirty and... More

My girlfriend and I stayed at the Anchor on a Sunday night in August. We arrived a few hours before check-in, but they were kind enough to let us drop our bags off, and offered the use of their bicycles. We walked into downtown to have a few drinks, the Inn is located literally steps from downtown, but is just... More

We came to the island for our wedding anniversary and Joey, Danny, Andy and Boomer made our stay amazing! The bedroom and bathroom were very clean. They really go all out for you and the breakfast was awesome. We were very happy we got a chance to spend some time with Andy watching a couple bands and we had a... More

My husband & I just returned from a two night stay @ The Anchor Inn B&B on Put-in-Bay. What a delightful find!! Joey, Danny & Andy made our time on the island very relaxing. The breakfast each morning was worth the trip. We were lucky to have great weather so that the meal was served under the Garden Gazebo in... More

We had not been to Put in Bay in years, and were looking for a quiet B&B to spend a few days on the island. The Anchor Inn met and exceeded our expectations! We stayed in the Captain's Suite on the first floor which was lovely. The breafkasts were great, especially the peach smoothie and the stuffed french toast. And... More