We loved our stay at Bayshore. The hotel was clean and the staff was very friendly and accommodating. The hotel is an easy walk to the downtown bar/restaurant area. The pool wasn't open yet, but looked clean and fun with a beautiful view of the lake. The view from the room was great with a screened in balcony on each... More

This was our first time to Put-in-Bay and we went for a Bachelorette party. We were a little hesitant about Bayshore because we read some of the reviews about the strict no alcohol policy etc. But everything was AWESOME. No one checked our bags/coolers and they were extremely nice and accommodating! The hotel itself was a little far from downtown... More

My husband and I have been to PIB a couple years now but always stayed at B&Bs. May 2011 we decided to splurge on a very great package and stay at the BayShore Resort. It was worth every single dime we spent, plus some and there is no doubt that we will be going back summer 2012 and every summer... More

We have vacationed in the Lake Erie Islands for 25 years and only recently started driving and staying in hotels rather than going by and staying on our boat. I was worried about finding a place at "The Bay" that would be suitable for traveling with a young child. Anyone familiar with Put-In-Bay KNOWS that Christmas in July weekend is... More

Nice for couples or older folks....2 clean pools not a human toilet like other pools in the area !! More

We have always had a girls weekend up @ PIB for many years. When this resort opened we started going to it. It is pricey but great rooms & view was fabulous. This year was different our room was not clean looking and the bathroom floor was bad. It just had that feel that it wasn't clean. Chairs and luggage... More

We just got home from a 2 night stay at the Bayshore. These previous reviews for the front desk, security, alcohol complaints- we did not experience ANY of that. The front desk workers were just fine- nice enough. Did not feel the need to be hugged and kissed upon arrival. When I made my reservation, I requested a 1st floor... More

Spent a girls weekend at the Bayshore resort the first weekend in August. Overall, the hotel is ideally located within walking distance (less than 5 min walk) to restaurants, bars, and shopping. The pool itself is sort of small, but it also wasn't packed while we were there. Large bathroom, and the shower is this really nice glass wall thing,... More

I have never spent so much on a mediocre hotel. You are paying for location based on supply and demand. Breakfast should have been included for as much as they charge. Also their online prices on the website did not match what we actually spent when we called and made reservations. Our room was very noisy because it was next... More