Love staying at the Island Club. Fall Ball and Spring Fling customer appreciation are the best. They always deliver a great time for all. The staff always goes out of their way to make sure we are comfortable and happy. They get to know you by name and make you feel like family. Jerry is the best and so easy... More

Love staying here. Their customer appreciation parties are a blast! Like having your own little summer house. More

We have been a long time renters of the houses at island club.Amy and I started in 1996 and still rent as of 2011.We have had nothing but good times and fond memories staying here. Every year, at least 2 times a year, we gather a group of couples up and head over to Island Club for fun weekend on... More

I stayed with 11 gals at the "A Place at the Bay" for my bachelorette party that was organized by my sister-in-law. I cannot take credit for the great place she selected - but I can say that it was perfect for what we wanted to achieve. The home was very large and very comfortably slept the 12 of us.... More

I would deffinately recommend Island Club Rentals for anyone planning a trip to Put in Bay. We were upgraded to one of the bigger 4 bedroom houses at no extra charge because we were going in the off season. The house was way more than we expected. Full size washer and dryer, big open well equipped kitchen with pots pans... More

I stayed at the "A Place at the Bay" house through Island Club Rentals with a group of 12 women this past weekend and we had a blast! The house was very roomy with enough beds for everyone and plenty of space to lounge. It never felt crowded. Although we had a chilly weekend, the patio and grill were a... More

Stayed for 2 nights at the Island Club. The 'cabins' are essentially double wide trailers. It was obvious that these cabins are used mostly for partying. Ammenities in our cabin were limitied, no sheets or towels provided (we brought our own). Many stains on the carpet, mattresses, etc. Very gross. The sliding glass door did not lock, which I felt... More

My family (myself, husband and four month old son) stayed at Island Club rentals from September 13-16, 2011. We had house #105. It was a wonderful place to stay while on the island and very afforadable after the main summer season. I made the reservation by phone and was emailed all necessary paperwork, which has to be emailed, faxed or... More

For the past 16 years, I have been going to Put In Bay with family and friends. The Island has something for everyone......nightlife and family life. Staying at the Island Club is one of the best deals on the island. If you don't want to stay in a hotel because you prefer having your own kitchen and deck, they offer... More