My daughter and I spent one night after Christmas to see the lake, eat at Mon Ami, and hike the nearby scenic spots. We stayed at Captain Montague's and were enchanted. Everything was lovely: our room (Molly's, made into twin beds), the hosts Judy and Mike, the breakfast, and the interior of the house (as well as the outside). So... More

We've made it a habit to see Mike and Judy at least once a year, not only for the food and hospitality, but because it works so well for the wonderful food opportunities close by. Driving 60 miles from Cleveland to Chez Francois and back, one of the best restaurants - if not THE best - in Ohio, can be... More

With all due respect to the review titled "An average B&B" from kmcCleveland_Ohio - Captain Montague's Bed and Breakfast, and its hosts, Mike and Judy, provide an experience that is anything but average. Sixteen years ago, I was a new mom who was taking her first time away since the birth of my son. My husband and I chose the... More

We very much enjoyed our stay and the great hospitality of Judy and her husband. Breakfast was excellent and Judy's brownies a soft and tasteful seduction at night. The interior of the house is most distinctive and reflects the effort and devotion of the owners to make this an unforgettable place. We were treated like friends! An excellent choice to... More

My husband and I and another couple stayed overnight in conjunction with a visit to the nearby (10 miles) Chez Francois restaurant in Vermilion, Ohio. Together, the restaurant and inn made for a wonderful weekend excursion. Our welcome could not have been more gracious by innkeeper Judy. She gave us a tour of the common areas and a history of... More

This was a B&B we chose to be close to a sailing school. The facility was clean and well-kept. Well-stocked guest galley. Breakfast was fine but not memorable. No dresser in the room and no stand to put our suitcases so we had to work out of them on the floor. The hosts were friendly but seemed to be a... More

Captain Montagues was everything we hoped when booking our 1st trip to a B&B. The owners were warm and informative. The home was beautiful and spotlessly clean. There was an inground pool & lovely outdoor area that we didn't get the opportunity to use, but it definitely adds to the property. I would highly recommend this B&B. Oh, and the... More

We stayed at Captain Montague's B&B in August 2011. We got to enjoy the hospitality of Judy and Mike and the very warm, welcoming and nicely decorated house, bedrooms and backyard. Judy and Mike are truly exceptional hosts and their house is a oasis of tranquility and comfort. Their backyard, patio, pool are so relaxing and comfortable. Their breakfast is... More

Captain Montague's is a gem and Mike and Judy are the gem keepers. We would echo what other reviews have said and add a few of our favorite things: It's like visiting a beautiful historic 19th century home but not having to stay behind the ropes; breathtaking chandeliers; Irish Santas; the welcoming personality of each guest room; a whimsy on... More