Went here for my birthday, my girlfriend had surprised me with getting us a room for the night. She knew I really wanted to go here because I had a friend who had passed away and he was a huge fan of the movie, the poem, and the song with "meet me in Montauk" quote in it. The room was... More

This hotel could rate 5 star, with minor changes in front desk customer service. We stayed at this hotel with a group of naturalists for seal observation, hiking and birding. The location is high on a hill with beautiful water views and is close to town and the Long Island Rail Road with friendly, complimentary shuttle service. The lobby is... More

Donna DeMarco helped coordinate for a group of 18 of us to attend the New Year's Eve party at Montauk Manor. She was super nice, helpful, and made everything smooth & simple. The hotel itself is very pretty from the outside and the lobby which is where the party was held is also super pretty. They had it decorated to... More

A large group of friends and I after much research decided to go spend NYE at Montauk Manor. After speaking with Donna, who was super helpful and informative, she helped coordinate our reservation and everything went so smoothly and without a hitch!!! Thanks to Donna we had so much fun dancing the night away at the most beautiful venue!!! More

Me and my group of friends celebrated NYE out at Montauk Manor to ring in 2012. The venue was absolutely fabulous, very beautiful!!!! The people were amazing, especially Donna Marco. She helped us coordinate 16 people in my party. And the dancing and partying were classic NYE memories. Eventhough we did not stay the night, I would highly recommend a... More

Stayed from 12/26-12/30. This hotel runs phenomenal specials in the "off" season. Frankly I love Montauk in the "off " season. We had a beautiful Deluxe 1 bedroom with 2 bathrooms and a super comfortable mattress on the pull out queen sofa bed. Our balcony overlooked Fort Pond Bay and the courtyard of the hotel and although it was chilly... More

My wife and I investigated New Year's eve options and spoke with Donna at the Montauk Manor. She was very helpful to find a room within our budget and let us know about the New Year's Eve package, with dinner and party on premises. She, together with Janice, was able to provide a room with a pull-out sofa in order... More

This was the first time I had ever visited and already I'm ready to go back. Considering I visited during the winter season and still loved this place I know that I will enjoy coming back in the summer as well. The exceptional service started with the driver, Patrick. He was not only nice but also very helpful; he knew... More

The kid from Florida - I think his name is Patrick - he's a big skateboarder - GREAT guy. He was so nice to my little boys. Had helpful suggestions about restaraunts. Really pleasant. We have gone back twice largely thanks to him. More