Checked in here on a Sunday for a two night stay. Was awakened early Monday by the manager to say he needed us to move to another room as they had made a mistake when we checked in. I asked if we could stay in the room we were given and manager said he had another rental coming that day.... More

We recently returned after 10 amazing days at the Surf Club where we stayed in a poolside/ocean view, one-bedroom duplex. We visit Montauk almost every year and this was the first time the weather fully cooperated. Surf Club's manager, Bill, was very helpful and accommodating and just a generally decent guy. Sylvester and Teresa were a pleasure to see each... More

We stayed at the Surf Club for the first time in July, 2011. We are a family of four (2 adults, 2 children). We stay in Montauk every year and usually at a different resort. We decided to try the Surf Club this year. We were lucky enough to book a room 6 weeks before our stay. It was a... More

Spent a week with kids and grandkids at this wonderful place right on the beach. Walk to a dozen decent restaurants. Very well-managed, rooms have great architecture combining convenience and privacy, the staff are friendly and well-trained (they seem to enjoy their work - a rarity these days!). Manager Bill Keskey is a jolly bear of a guy, helpful and... More

The bottom line... Location A+ Units C to B Depending on whether or not unit owner has renovated (BTW this is unfortunately typical for Montauk) Management F When questioned as to why the "ortho man" would be spraying poolside midday while kids were swimming the manager resorted to: 1. lies ("the spray is organic" - this lie was debunked by... More

Just returned from Surf Club vacation and had a very relaxing stay. We stayed in a 1 bedroom Oceanfront room. Pros: Very short walk to the beach. The grounds were beautiful and the staff was very helpful. People at the "resort" were very pleasant and trustworthy. If you left your sandals at the end of the boardwalk you knew they... More

Just got back from staying at the Surf Club. After reading some of the reviews that the place needed serious remodeling, I was a little hesitant to book here, but when I called, I was assured that most of the units were, in fact, remodeled. We stayed in a one bedroom oceanview that was great - new kitchen, new floor... More

This is really the best place to stay in Montauk. It is on the beach, close to the restaurants and it is the nicest place in town. It is ridiculously expensive (as are all hotels in Montauk) - but the only place that is acceptable. More

Staying here at the SurfClub for memorial day weekend 2011. So far I can tell you that this resort has the best location in Montauk. That's about all for the pro's. As for the cons...I'm in an oceanfront 1 bedroom duplex and although I can see the ocean, I do not see the beach. I dint think you can see... More