We decided to go to Montauk at the last minute this past weekend and found a room at the Surf Lodge. Conveniently located within walking distance of the train, we go to the hotel and checked in. The rooms are awesome. We walked in and found a reasonably sized room with an efficiency kitchen. The bed faced sliding glass doors... More

The rooms were clean, the Irish girls at front desk very friendly, the management team amazing.Overall a very nice experience. We will be back for sure. More

I would not recommend this Hotel. The attitude and bad service unfortunately overshadow the fairly decent product. The room was nice with a small deck and hammock overlooking the lake. Towels had stains, the shower sprayed on the ceiling dripping "yellow" water down whilst showering. YUK! One staff member we encountered was very polite and helpful, the rest did not... More

Nice spot but staff are way to full of themselves for my liking. Been going every summer for past three years but unlikely to stay again due to the arrogant and unfriendly nature of the staff. More

If you're looking for gold dresses and classic Hamptons setting, Montauk might not be the place for you. But if you want to see a more real side of the Hamptons, love to surf and like to move your friends from Lower Eastside to the seaside this is the place to be. The Surf Lodge has been a hipster paradice... More

Not your 'typical' hotel/lodge. Very different. It's an older establishment located on Fort Pond. Every room has a balcony facing the pond with, a hammock and chair. We had a superior room(#18), large, with huge closet. Very comfortable bed, kitchenette (frig, micro, coffee-maker, and kitchen ware), and very clean. ... No phone! (Great). The staff are absolutely wonderful - Irish... More

Was really torn as to whether to stay here since the reviews were so mixed. Now I undertand why there is such opposing views - this place doesn't easily fall into a category. Its priced like a resort where you'd find lots of activities and amenities, but they are just not there. Instead, what you get is a location on... More

Tough to review. During previous trips the restaurant was the place to be, which used to make up for the horrible food and service. That is no longer the case. No longer worth the trip. More

Did a weekend with my girl and felt like I was a kid again. This place was super fun and hip. Rooms were a little on the small side but a great palce to chill away from the crowd. I will try to make this a place I visit every summer. We needed a cab to get into town but... More