My husband and I stayed at the Waterstone Inn for two nights (November 7 and 8). The Inn had regained its power a few days earlier, though many folks in the area were still waiting for theirs. The Mulcahy family are the nicest folks you will ever meet; everyone is warm, friendly and responsive to whatever guests may need during... More

We stayed at the Waterstone Inn a few days after Superstorm Sandy on our way to Newark Airport from Vermont - every hotel within an hour of the airport was booked as the next morning was the first day Newark was open for international flights. What a find! I can not emphasise strongly enough how amazing the Mulcahys were -... More

I stayed here during an impromptu getaway trip from New York City and I must say, I was blown away by how amazing this B&B was. Here are a few reasons why: -They took our last minute reservation and waited up for us to arrive -The room was impeccable, comfortable, and exceeded my expectations -The property was clean, filled with... More

Returned for a quick getaway to recharge. Once again can not emphasize how great it was. The Mulcahy's are such a warm family and just make you feel so welcomed. The food was once again above and beyond. Sitting on the front porch watching the lake was just what I needed. I came home feeling relaxed and recharged. Amazing and... More

WaterStone Inn Montclair Room. This is a beautiful place, hosted by a very nice family: friendly and extremely accommodating. They’ve been in business for a few years, but the Inn still looks brand new: everything is clean and very well kept. All furniture and accessories are well thought out. Sheets & towels are of noticeably high quality. Hot water is... More

My husband Philip & I found The Waterstone Inn, Miriam, Dennis & family to be absolutely faultless. We've been back 3 times at different times of the year to discover more of the beautiful Greenwood Lake area, & each time we have a perfect vacation experience. The rooms are spacious & always perfectly clean, superbly comfortable with fabulous spa baths!... More

This was my family's first stay at a Bed&Breakfast. My sister and I are child actors so we have stayed in many big hotels before. The Waterstone Inn was unbelievable. The rooms were impeccable and so comfortable. My sister and I caught so many fish off the dock while my parents relaxed on the deck, enjoying the beautiful view of... More

A great getaway spot that was close, but far enough away from it all! The Mulcahy family running the Inn is fantastic and the room was immaculate. Everything about the stay was A+. I would definitely recommend.

My wife and I took the opportunity to visit our son who lives and works in New York State. After spending time reviewing hotels in the area my son suggested we stay at the Waterstone Inn as it was close to his work and used often by his company when visiting clients were in the area. The Inn was exceptional.... More