Buddy and I stayed at the Belvedere Guest House for the first time during Memorial Day weekend. Our stay was enjoyable. We stay in a luxury room because we wanted our own bathroom (instead of sharing with other guests). The room was small but nice. There's no air conditioning but it wasn't really necessary in late May as the room... More

I was at the Belvedere 6 to the 10 of Sep.2012 staff was very nice my room was nice and clean yes it was a little run down in parts but still had a nice look about it i would be happy to good back and stay the next time i go to Fire Island verynice pool area was very... More

This place is a total dump. Do not believe the pictures on their site. This place is full of disgusting old men. I'm a good looking young guy hit this place in July and would have left right away if I had not prepaid the stay. The rooms are horrible and very expensive. Was there couple nights and my room... More

The staff were incredibly friendly, couldn't fault them really, the pool area is lovely as are some of the decking areas and courtyard. The overall look of the hotel I really quite liked. Its a really nice relaxed no attitude style atmosphere. That said though the hotel does feel a little run down in parts, the bedrooms smells a bit... More

My friend and I came to stay at the Belvedere on the recomendation of a friend who had been there a few years ago. This past weekend wasour first experience in Cherry Grove/ Fire Island. The Cherry Grove community is wonderful, restaurants are vastly over priced but the area is wonderful. The BELVEDERE Hotel is a mess. We entered the... More

This was my first time in what was advertised as "an elegant" experience. I must admit, at one time, the place must have been wonderful but that was definitely in the past. The hotel is not clean and reeks of stale cigarette smoke from days gone by. If the sheets on the bed were clean, it was when they came... More

You certainly would not expect such a crazy eccentric Venetian Building in that area of the world as the place is more surrendered by modern architects wooden houses! I have stayed on Fire Island before but always dreamed of pushing the door of that very private almost secret property! Did it now and do not regret at all! As you... More

Overall, the price is outrageous for what it is, but then again, everything on Fire Island is overpriced... and in general it does have a very sexual atmosphere (not quite a bath house, but a lot more sexual than any other clothing optional place I've ever stayed at) - you will see people having sex in the common areas -... More

I think these negative reviewers were writing on backwards day because I had nothing short of an amazing experience here. The decor has major character and the staff were super friendly. The building itself is older but not dank, musty, or whatever else was said. It's clean and has a lot of charm, the pool area is perfect and you... More