My husband and I stayed at the Jolly Roger for two nights (weekend) in July. It is at the very end of the island at the barricade. The location is great because it is very quiet. Amy was helpful in giving us excellent restaurant recommendations (we highly recommend the Maine Course). The room was basic, but it was clean and... More

I was told they do not allow kids or pets, which as an older adult meant a peaceful vacation for me. We stayed there the last week of July 2012. LBI is about 20 miles long and only has about 20 hotels, 99% of it is residential. Therefore, there is no such thing as a cheap hotel on the island,... More

We stayed at the Jolly Roger over the 4th of July and had a great time. Our room looked right at the ocean and the beach was just across the street. We could see 20 or more fireworks displays from the rooftop deck. Nice place for a beach getaway.

We stayed at the Jolly Roger and I was won over by Amy's friendliness over the phone. It cost $180 because it was the high season. The room was nice and there were no bed bugs. I was disappointed that there was no shampoo, conditioner, shower gel or lotion. I expected that because the room rate wasn't cheap. There was... More

My friend Scott and I stayed at the Jolly Roger for the first time in the many years we have been traveling to LBI. Do not let the modest exterior deter you. The rooms were clean and comfortable. While they were small, they definitely fit our needs and are perfect for a couple or two friends to stay at. It's... More

I have been going to LBI for over 25 years, staying in various accommodations and settings. I had never stayed as far south as the Jolly Roger. I called a couple of weeks ago for a one night stay (which is difficult to find during high season) and Amy, the manager, was able to accommodate me and my friend. Upon... More

I can say this hotel's customer service is incredible. I called them at midnight on a friday in the summer to get a last minute room for an employee who had been stuck working a wedding until very late. He had a 2 hour drive home and was exhausted. Amy, the manager, informed me that she had one room but... More

I stayed at this hotel with my daughter for a two nite mother /daughter get away. The rooms were nice size and the they were had a good size frig and microwave. Additionally, there is an attached private porch with a table and four chairs which gives you a side view of the ocean...which is right across the street. The... More

At first I was a bit skeptical about this quaint motel at Beach Haven. However, I gave in and forgot about the boardwalk, go carts, and packed beaches of my other favorite New Jersey beach spots. When my partner and I arrived early our room was cleaned and ready. The staff was very nice and friendly, always giving us suggestions... More