We stayed with Angie and Tim for a week. The room was clean. The grounds well kept and beautiful. Angie checked in with us every day to make sure all was well and Marie kept our room clean and stocked with neccesary items. We were so sad to leave but will definitely return in the near future. More

The Coral Bay Resort was beautiful. The room was clean. The grounds are exquisite. The fishing was great right there - you could catch the fish there and cook it right on the barbeque!I took my son there and can't wait to go back. We had a fantastic time. The managers were friendly and helpful. The sunsets were breathtaking. Do... More

My husband and I stumbled upon Coral Bay Resort on our way up from Key West. Angie the manager was so pleasant and accommodating and the grounds were beautiful we decided to stay. What a lovely experience! The rooms are clean and fresh, the pool is perfectly warmed and clean and the tide pool and beach/dock areas are a real... More

My fiance and I had heard about Coral Bay and several other very nice vacation spots in the Florida Keys through various caterers while we were trying to plan our wedding. Living in Fort Lauderdale, we are not terribly far away from this little gem. We chose the Coral Bay Resort because of it's exceptional beauty and space. We decided... More

We love Coral Bay for its exceptionally quaint setting, its beauty, and for the friends that we get together with year after year! However, as has been reported by others, our last vacation there was the most unpleasant experience that one could imagine, because of the gnarly nature of the office manager. She had no people skills and would be... More

The ambiance cannot be duplicated anywhere in the Florida Keys. I've been coming here since before 2009. When I recently recommended it to friends, they were skeptical after reading some Trip Advisor reviews. Unfortunately, those bad reviews appear to be related to an abrasive and undiplomatic office manager, who has since been replaced! I understand that the new management is... More

I read the reviews sitting in the car while my husband went in and talked to Angie. First thing he said when he returned was how friendly she was. She and her husband have been the new managers only two weeks, so please disregard earlier reviews about rude management. The place is great: cute little beach, lovely pool, nice clean... More

My husband and I were refered here by the Florida Visitors Center while we were making our way down the keys. We had no plans. We just wanted a beach. It is such a cute, quiet little place. It only has 18 or so rooms. Has a protected beach, huge deck, pool, spots to dock boats. Sat on deck and... More

We have been enjoying coral bay resort for several years now, but the management has something to be desired. the desk woman made us feel like were a burden rather than a loyal customer, she put us in a room that was at the front of the complex next to the office, after I had let her know the area... More