Have been fortunate to stay here on two occasions(June and Nov 2011) and here's why I can't wait to get back: Staff - outstanding from top to bottom! They treat you like family and cater to your every whim. If they can't put a smile on your face and meet your every expectation, you must be a sourpuss! Food -... More

I've traveled extensively and stayed in some pretty nice hotels. Exotic is by no means a luxury resort -- but I would stay here again without a doubt. My beachfront room was literally strides from the water. While the water off the beach wasn't really swim-able (this is true pretty much everywhere on the island) there was a perfect swimming... More

Wow...we were amazed at the hospitality at the Exotic Caye Beach Resort. The staff and management are the best that I have been around in all of San Pedro. The views are incredible and can be seen from every room at the resort. If you are in the mood for a fresh coconut, ask Maitlin to cut one down for... More

Spent a wonderful 5 days at Exotic Caye Feb 2012 and can't wait to go back. The rooms were spotless, the beach was gorgeous but most of all, the staff was amazing - what a great bunch of folks! We've stayed at 5 or 6 other places in San Pedro, but this is the spot we plan on returning to.... More

Great location with all units having a water view. This is a well managed place where every guest is given VIP treatment. More

Just back from a very enjoyable one week stay at Exotic Caye Beach Resort. I would rate this property at about a 2.5 to 3 star type property. We stayed in a two bedroom unit - 4A. Property - The units are all older but are very clean and well maintained. There is one bar and one restaurant on site... More

The staff was all very friednly, the bed was comfortable, and the kitchenette was well equipped. The problem was there wasn't anything to do around the resort. The "pool" was an oversized bath tub and although the beach was close you couldn't swim because of the sea grass. This was an issue for most of the resorts around San Pedro.,... More

We arrived yesterday and already find this place to be excellent. The location is wonderful, the staff is beyond excellent, the grounds are gorgeous, the food excellent, the water is amazing. This place is 6-star in my book! Offers simple 2-room suites that are rustic and clean. They have a kitchen with a real stove, refrigerator (mini), coffee maker, plates,... More

Just returned from a wonderful trip to Exotic Caye! Like all the recent reviews, I agree, the staff at this resort are fantastic. Soooo friendly & helpful! As you can see by the photos, the resort has a great rustic island feel. It is not a fancy high-rise place so if you are looking for that, this is not the... More