This is the second time we've stayed here and have not been disappointed. It's not the Ritz, but we much prefer local ambience to staying with spoiled rich kids. Phyllis is down to earth and a super innkeeper. She provides you with everything you need for a comfortable stay. The hill is a tough climb but after a couple of... More

We stayed in the Front Suite in Early November 2011. The room was clean and well stocked with liquor, drink mixes, bacon, eggs, coffee, and various other small food items. Phyllis was very helpful, even coming to find us and lead us back to the house when we got lost after arriving and picking up our rental car. It is... More

Phyllis, the owner, was wonderful. Our room was stocked with wine, rum, breakfast foods, cold drinks, and even ice cream! We had a nice view of Cruz Bay and the use of coolers, snorkel gear, and free DVDs to watch in the evening. Our room was a little worn and the bathroom needed a little attention, but the outstanding price... More

I stayed here as it was one of the cheapest places to stay on the island (not cheap in general terms however) but was disappointed mainly with the standard of cleanliness and the insect infestations but let's start with the positives : Pros - excellent location, walking distance to cruz bay shops and restaurants (however the steep hill climb was... More

I chose Hillcrest after reading consistent online reviews for 2 years. My last visit to St. John I stayed at Caneel Bay which is extremely pricey. I have to say I enjoyed this trip even more! The owner of the Hillcrest was so welcoming and such a lovely woman. I loved her dogs as well! We stayed in the Front... More

I had a wonderful time staying here. The place was beautiful, the view was spectacular and the owner was such a pleasure to be around. I think everyone will have an experience like mine when staying here. You will not find another place as welcoming on the island. The owner really makes you feel like family. More

Hillcrest is in a perfect location, easy walk to town (the hill is steep but not very long) and quick walk to Frank Bay for great local snorkeling. We stayed there for 3 nights in April 2011 and loved it. Phyllis is a wonderful host and supplied us with some staples in the fridge, not to mention delicious island rum.... More

We spent 3 nights at the Hillcrest Guest House on St. John this week. I wasn't for sure of my online choice when we pulled up, but the owner has made it a clean and comfortable place to stay. I enjoy staying at places that are not "chain hotel types". This one reminded me of a restored plantation cottage we... More

This charming guesthouse has several studio housekeeping apartments with everything you could want for your stay, not only pots and pans but also snorkel equipment, cooler and beach chairs! The thoughtful owner also gives you a welcome basket of food goodies and some basic breakfast items to cook, plus a bottle each of rum and wine. Nice covered outdoor lounge... More