My husband and I spent the weekend in Bayfield for our 37th Anniversary. I read the reviews of Judy's Gourmet Garage so I wanted to stop in and try some pastries. We were SO glad that we did! The first time we went, we bought some totally yummy fresh apple cider cake doughnuts and some great cookies. The morning we... More

I had read the reviews about this place and the folks we were visiting in nearby Lake Nebagmona also raved about the food. There was one reviewer who claimed the pies were now made with canned pie filling. Not possible! Everything we tried was awesome (I know it is an overused adjective, but can't think of a better description). The... More

This was our first stop on our way into town and we stopped in every day of our vacation to reload on cookies, turnovers and other assorted goodies! More

The bakery looks good but is not fresh ingredients. Cookies were stale - hard as a rock. Pies were made from canned pie filling - not fresh. Judy apparently has decided to take shortcuts in her old age and the quality is not worth the money. More

You won't be disappointed with the pies. And it doesn't seem possible, but the turnovers are better! A true gem - and make sure to say hello to the resident fat cat who hangs outside the garage. We pass up the Apple Festival every year but make certain we make a trip to the Gourmet Garage. More

Oh, how does one describe taste bud nirvana? This is an extra special bakery we discovered in Bayfield, WI. I have traveled to this region for year and discovered this gem on our last trip that produces the best ,made from scratch, pies I have ever had…sorry Mom. We tried a Tripleberry (blue berries, black berries, and black raspberries) pie.... More

We bought a strawberry rhubarb pie, cookies and turnovers. The pie was very good. The cookies were good. But the turnovers were excellent! Best I've ever had. More

While camping in Bayfield, I made the trip over to the Gourmet Garage for a blueberry turnover every morning. Things were fresh and hot and dare I say...buttery smooth!!! These ladies ROCK my world and I will be back again to beautiful Bayfield for some of the best pie on this earth.....that is if the bears don't get there first!!! More

We were warmly greeted. Staff were friendly and helpful and we left with some of the yummiest, hot-from-the-oven pies you could imagine! More