This was the fourth year that my son and I attended the Haunted Dinner Theater at Captain George's. It has been fun every year. It is fun meeting the other people at your table and trying to figure out who did it. The food is always excellent. You get plenty of time to visit the buffet before the show starts... More

The line to get it gets long fast but once they open the doors things move fast. They really need to make accomidations for those who can't stand in line. Also was a good walk to get in line for the buffet. The show was OK, The food was good for buffet. Was fun meeting and speaking with others that... More

The buffet was not good. Very limited choice. food was not teasty not good. You can get much better food with lot of varites in any other ordinary restaurant. The only thing you can eat was desert. The show was very very boaring. Performers were just walking around the tables from this wall to that wall, it became very difficult... More

The show was "cute" and the actors did a great job with the limited props and such. The show is more of a who done it then a scary haunted theme and I would have no problem with my 9 year old seeing it. The food was great during our visit and never had a problem getting any crab legs... More

The buffet was great. Skip the " entertainment" and go directly to buffet. Must be quick near the crab legs, people just grab and shove to get at them ! More

Our family visited this Haunted Dinner Theater about 10 years ago. We enjoyed it and the food. Children are now teenagers and we have returned to Williamsburg and wanted to do the theater again. This time very, very disappointing. I was amazed at how we had to wind throught the establishment to get to the buffet in the regular restaurant.... More

Date October 15,2009 Dinner Theatre taking place with Captain George's Seafood Buffet. $44.95 per person. Started at 7 p.m. and we were out by 9 p.m. Theatre was very close quarters having to squeeze out between chairs to get to the buffet. The first hour was spent trying to get to the buffet and squeezing back into our seat [... More

If your planning on going to Caption Georges for dinner, you might as pay the extra money for dinner and a show. While the food was good, it was not worth the price nor did it live up to the hype. As for the dinner theater itself, it was quite entertaining but had a few faults. One of the actors... More

We went to Captain George's as part of their "Haunted Dinner" program. The show was ok, but the buffet did not live up to the hype, or the online menu. According to their online description, those who are part of the Mystery Dinner Theater are supposed to have their own buffet, identical to that at which people apparently have to... More