Koal Keel served up some of the most innovative cuisine I have ever had. First, the restaurant sent a shuttle to pick us up (they run a FREE shuttle service to many of the hotels on the island). This was perfect because we didn't want to drink and drive. The restaurant is lovely. The server helped us choose an amazing... More

Take the tour of the plantation house, rum store and wine cellar. Food is good, not great. Skip the chicken that takes 24 hours to prepare in the rock oven. It was dry and bland. Great wine list and the other items on the menu are good. More

We ate at Koal Keel on the recommendation of an Anguilla blog and the concierge at our resort-both said this was the BEST restaurant on the island. The food and service just didn't live up to the hype and the setting. It's a pity, as the building is a very charming plantation house with a lovely dining room-beautiful mahogany, stone... More

When visiting Anguilla, this up-scale restaurant is a must. Koal Keel is a 200 year old sugar plantation that was lovingly restored by a local Anguillan, Lisa Gumbs. The ambiance is unmatched and makes for a perfect setting for a romantic dinner or celebratory event. The entire staff was friendly, helpful, and provided top-notch service. If you call ahead (24... More